Have I Saved Too Much For Retirement


What Do You Want From Your Money

5 Signals You are SAVING TOO MUCH for Retirement

I hate to answer a question with a question, but really we don’t have enough information to tell you if you are “saving too much.”

Do you want to retire early? You might not be saving enough!

Do you want to put your kids through Ivy League college debt free? Maybe you need to shift some of your future savings to a 529 education plan.

Do you want to drive a fancy car? Maybe you should put some of that extra pay in regular old savings.

It’s all about what you want from your money.

If you don’t know what you want, well, over-investing in your retirement is probably a safe thing to do while you figure it out!

I would argue that in a world of compounding interest, that is, where time beats interest rates there is no such thing as “saving too much”. Without knowing your goals it is impossible to tell.

I have around 30k in a regular savings account along with another 30k for my childrens education fund.

The key question here is therefore not if you have saved too much for retirement but are your other financial goals are in line with your expectations, i.e. are you comfortable with the amounts in your savings account and the children’s education fund? . Nobody can tell but you yourself.

Set Your Retirement Goals

How much you need to save depends on how you want to spend your retirement. Think about:

  • your travel plans
  • your age when you retire
  • if you’ll work after you retire
  • if you’ll have children or grandchildren to support
  • where you want to live
  • whether youll have debt to pay, such as a mortgage or a loan

Retirement Savings In Your 60s

You are close to retirement. At age 60, plan to have 8 times your annual income, and at age 65, a 9-10 Ã multiple or more would be excellent.

At age 65, the Old Age Security pensionstarts. Combined with the CPP, these benefits may account for up to an average of $15,654.48 per year based on the current average numbers for 2021.

Your retirement savings fill the gaps in your retirement income needs since CPP and OAS alone wonât be enough.

You can learn about how these pension benefits work in this retirement guide.

Your investment portfolio continues to require attention. While it is advisable to lower your risk exposure in retirement, some level of risk is required if you want your returns to exceed the inflation rate.

Keep your cash holdings in a high interest account that pays a reasonable interest rate TFSA Savings, RRSP Savings, or General Savings.

If you are in doubt about your plan, consult a certified financial advisor or planner. For a retirement calculation that takes your CPP, RRSP, workplace pension, and more into consideration, .

Read Also: How Much Of Your Paycheck Should You Save For Retirement

Take A Good Look At The Numbers

Many people who are not saving enough have simply not taken the time to figure out exactly how much they need. The same is probably true of people who are saving too much for retirement.

If you use a retirement planning calculator that is detailed and personalized enough to help you feel confident about your future, then you may be better able to relax your tendency toward saving. The NewRetirement Planner even lets you try different scenarios so you can feel confident about how much you might need given different sets of contingencies.

Annuity Vs Drawdown Whats The Best Option

Can You Save Too Much for Retirement?

Since 2015, people have been free to either purchase an annuity or go into drawdown, but whats the best option?


An annuity provides a guaranteed income for life. The income you receive either remains the same or can increase over time in line with inflation.

The main benefit of purchasing an annuity is the certainty and security it provides. You will receive an income for as long as you live.

The main drawback of purchasing an annuity is the pitiful income it provides. For example, if you use your £200,000 pension to purchase an annuity at 60, you will receive just £4,848 per year. This assumes that the annuity increases each year and pays your spouse an income if you die.


The other option is to go into income drawdown. This is where you keep your pension pot invested and withdraw money as and when you need it.

The main benefit of a drawdown pension is that you have complete control and flexibility. You can choose to withdraw as little or as much as you like, whenever you like.

The main drawback of a drawdown pension is that if you withdraw too much, you will run out of money. Think of your drawdown pension like your bank account. If you withdraw too much, you will eventually have nothing left.

Whats the best option?

The best option will depend on your circumstances.

If you dont have enough income to meet the basics, you may want to purchase an annuity. This way youll always know that you have enough to cover the essentials.

Also Check: Baylor Scott And White Retirement Plan

Putting It All Together

After you’ve answered the above questions, you have a few options.

The table below shows our calculations, to give you an estimate of a sustainable initial withdrawal rate. Note that the table shows what you’d withdraw from your portfolio thisyear only. You would increase the amount by inflation each year thereafteror ideally, re-review your spending plan based on the performance of your portfolio.

We assume that investors want the highest reasonable withdrawal rate, but not so high that your retirement savings will run short. In the table, we’ve highlighted the maximum and minimum suggested first-year sustainable withdrawal rates based on different time horizons. Then, we matched those time horizons with a general suggested asset allocation mix for that time period. For example, if you are planning on needing retirement withdrawals for 20 years, we suggest a moderately conservative asset allocation and a withdrawal rate between 4.9% and 5.4%.

The table is based on projections using future 10-year projected portfolio returns and volatility, updated annually by Charles Schwab Investment Advisor, Inc. . The same annually updated projected returns are used in retirement saving and spending planning tools and calculators at Schwab.

The Benchmarks For Those Closer To Retirement

The range gets wider as you get older, so we also provide more detailed estimates for people approaching retirement. This helps someone find a realistic target based on income and marital status, which affect Social Security benefits.

A Closer Look at Savings Benchmarks Later in Your Career

Savings Benchmarks Later in Your Career

11x 14x

Assumptions: See Savings Benchmarks by AgeAs a Multiple of Income above. Dual income means that one spouse generates 75% of the income that the other spouse earns.

Don’t Miss: What Is The Average Retirement Savings

Why It Pays To Start Early

While it is never too late to start saving and planning for retirement, the earlier you start, the better. Starting earlier means more time for your savings to benefit from the effects of compounding returns.

Conversely, the longer you wait, the less time you have for your money to grow and the harder you’ll have to work to reach your retirement goals.

Just how much of a difference does it make to start early?

How Will You Invest Your Portfolio

Can I save too much for retirement?

Stocks in retirement portfolios provide potential for future growth, to help support spending needs later in retirement. Cash and bonds, on the other hand, can add stability and can be used to fund spending needs early in retirement. Each investment serves its own role, so a good mix of all threestocks, bonds and cashis important. We find that asset allocation has a relatively small impact on your first-year sustainable withdrawal amount, unless you have a very conservative allocation and long retirement period. However, asset allocation can have a significant impact on the portfolio’s ending asset balance. In other words, a more aggressive asset allocation may have the potential to grow more over time, but the downside is that the “bad” years can be worse than with a more conservative allocation.

You May Like: Retirement Homes In Mesa Az

The Effects Of Inflation

All of us have to cope with the impact of inflation. Consider how inflation affects your cost of living:

  • If the inflation rate is at 3%, the cost of living would double every 24 years
  • If the inflation rate increases to 4%, the cost of living would double every 18 years

If inflation grows faster than your retirement savings, it could mean that:

  • You’ll need to adjust your expenditure
  • Your present retirement funds may not last throughout your retirement
  • There is a chance that you may outlive your savings

Consider The Side Effects Of Financial Security

When it comes to money, you don’t want to leave your future up to chance. Having more than you need for retirement can help you “to sleep at night,” says Marshall.

Another benefit of investing a lot of money in your retirement accounts is that you can then “be more charitable and help others,” says Lane Martinsen, author of “The Holistic Retirement Planning Revolution” and principal of Martinsen Wealth Management.

Of those clients, he adds: “They can see their donation at work while they are still alive and that is really important to them. Some never planned to do this, but as their assets have grown they are able to donate.”

You May Like: Empower Retirement 401k Loan Repayment

Cover All Unknowns And Worst Case Scenarios

We simply dont know what will happen in the future and it is best to make sure that you have enough savings to cover potential unanticipated possibilities.

This is one of the reasons why so many people feel like no amount will ever be enough.

Anticipating unknowns and creating financial back up plans is a good practice for retirement planning. It is especially a good idea for those who are struggling with the idea of whether or not they have saved too much or not enough.

The NewRetirement Planner is an excellent tool that enables you to model multiple scenarios. It can help you make sure you address the obvious unknowns: long term care, healthcare costs and home maintenance concerns. But, you can also make a list of everything that worries you a grandchild who might need expensive medical care or a fire at your home for example and create a plan that you can feel good about.

Not everything unanticipated will actually happen, but you will absolutely be more certain that you are prepared for what does.

Overstuffing Your Retirement Accounts

How Much Should You Have Saved By 30? What

Not everyone is allowed to contribute to retirement accounts. Contributions to an IRA or Roth IRA require you or your spouse to have earned income such as wages, salary, bonuses, commissions, tips or self-employment income. Pension payments, Social Security benefits, rental income and interest and dividends dont count. Also, the ability to contribute to a Roth phases out at modified adjusted gross incomes between $125,000 and $140,000 for single filers, from $198,000 to $208,000 for married couples filing jointly.

People may not realize that the annual limit on IRA contributions $6,000 for 2021, plus a catch-up contribution of $1,000 for people 50 and over is the cap for all IRA accounts. In other words, you cant contribute $6,000 to a traditional IRA and another $6,000 to a Roth IRA in the same year.

You also can contribute too much to a workplace plan such as a 401, especially if you change jobs during the year. Your new employer wont know if youve already made contributions to your previous employers plan that would count toward the annual limits , says tax expert Mark Luscombe, principal analyst at Wolters Kluwer Tax & Accounting.

You May Like: Purchase An Annuity For Retirement

How Much Money Do You Need To Retire At 60

As a general rule of thumb, you need 20 25 times your retirement expenses. So, if you spend £30,000 per year, youll need £600,000 £750,000 in pensions, investments and savings.

However, most people will receive some form of income in retirement, whether thats a State Pension, final salary pension, rental income or something else entirely.

Therefore, youll need to deduct this from any income you receive.

So if you spend 30,000 per year and receive a State Pension of £8,000 and a final salary pension of £2,000, the actual amount you need per year is only £20,000.

How Long Will My Retirement Savings Last

It depends on how much you saved, how much you spend each year, your investment returns, and more. One way to look at this is to use the 4% withdrawal rule.

What this rule of thumb infers is that if you withdraw 4% of your savings every year, you should have enough money to last you through retirement

Some of the assumptions of this rule include:

  • Your investment portfolio is invested in stocks and it generates a healthy return.
  • You have some flexibility with income withdrawals. For example, in a bad financial year, you may lower your withdrawal amount by a few percentage points.
  • You increase your annual withdrawal by the inflation rate to account for decreasing purchasing power.

Assuming you have a portfolio of $1 million. Using the 4% withdrawal rule, you will withdraw $40,000 in the first year of retirement and adjust to inflation in later years.

Downsides of the 4% Rule

It assumes you are partly invested in stocks. Depending on your risk tolerance and financial circumstances, a 50% or more asset allocation of stocks can be too risky.

If the financial markets suffer a prolonged decline during your early retirement years, your withdrawals could cut too deep into your principal and it may recover.

This is also referred to as the sequence of returns risk and it works both ways .

Todayâs low-interest-rate environment does not bode well for savers and makes a 4% withdrawal ambitious if you are invested in money market instruments.

Recommended Reading: Best Mutual Funds To Invest In For Retirement

A Big Pile Of Money Is Great But It Raises Questions

  • Resize icon


I recently had a conversation with a colleague about retirement and was told Im saving too much! My wife and I are both 57 and have been aggressive savers ever since my brother, an institutional retirement financial expert, told us to max out our savings when we were 25 years old. As a result, we have saved 25-30% of our income and invested aggressively over the years. We have a very healthy nest egg in the low- to mid-seven figures and no debt other than our home, which is very low interest and will be paid off before retirement. Our children have no student debt. My colleague says we are postponing our lives and creating tax problems for when we retire. We have never felt like we have missed out on anything by saving and have lived a full life but is there such a thing as saving too much?


Live for today or save for tomorrow?

Dear Live for Today or Save for Tomorrow,

Ill start with the answer you may not have expected: Yes, there is such a thing as saving too much money, financial advisers said. That doesnt necessarily mean you personally have saved too much, though.

Having an overfunded retirement isnt a bad problem to have, but it does raise the question: what are your goals for your finances, the present and your future, and are you meeting them? A big pile of money is great, but its even better when you get to use it the way you want. There is no one right answer here, as the situation differs from person to person.

Not Personalizing Retirement Planning

Saving TOO Much?? 5 Signs You’re Saving Too Much For Retirement | Your Retirement Authority

One big reason you may be saving too much is that retirement planning has become too generalized. With the advent of online calculators and personal finance software, tech providers have built too many general assumptions into their technology.

Not all assumptions work for all people. Everyone has a different life situation that cannot be easily packaged into a smartphone app or represented by a few numbers that you enter into an online calculator.

For example, it’s unlikely that any automated program will be able to accurately predict how much of your pre-retirement income you will needotherwise known as replacement rateand what the return rates, inflation, and spending will be throughout your retirement years.

Recommended Reading: Best Way To Invest Money For Retirement

Building A Retirement Plan

What does it take to draw up a retirement plan? Here are the steps you’ll need to go through:

Step 1: Define your retirement goals

  • How much do you estimate you will need, to retire with the lifestyle you hope to have? You can use a retirement calculator to work it out.

Step 2: Assess your current situation

  • Review your finances to see if you are on track to reaching your retirement goals.

Step 3: Close your savings gap

  • How can you accumulate funds for your retirement?
  • Cut spending and save more.

Looking At Your Personal Goals

The important task here is to look at your personal goals both short-term goals and long-term goals.

For the short-term, you need to make sure that you have a large enough emergency fund to cover any unexpected expenses that may arise. If you know that youre going to need to buy a car in the next few years, or if youre looking to purchase a house and need a down payment, then you should save for that appropriately outside of retirement accounts. Keep it in a basic savings account or in a regular taxable account.

For the long-term, you need to think hard about when you want to retire. If youre going to be working into your 60s anyway because you need to, then saving in retirement accounts makes a lot of sense. However, if your goal is to retire at 50 or 55, then you should consider having large amount of money outside of retirement accounts, such as in traditional brokerage accounts. This will give you a big enough cushion should you retire early.

You might also consider diversifying into other assets like cash flowing real estate, that can provide for you earlier.

Read Also: The Virginian Retirement Home Fairfax

Share post:


More like this

Sign Up For Ssi Retirement

Do Social...

Empower Retirement 401k Loan Repayment

Fidelity Vs...

Berkeley Retirement Home Lawrence Ma

Assisted Living...

Kentucky Retirement System Health Insurance

Message From...