Is It Better To Combine Retirement Accounts


This Tax Information Is Not Intended

Consolidate Your Retirement Accounts? 6 Pros and 2 Cons

This tax information is not intended to be a substitute for specific individualized tax, legal, or investment planning advice. Where specific advice is necessary or appropriate, Schwab recommends that you consult with a qualified tax advisor, CPA, financial planner, or investment manager. Depending on the type of account you have, there are different rules for withdrawals, penalties, and distributions. Please understand these before opening your account.

A rollover of retirement plan assets to an IRA is not your only option. Carefully consider all of your available options which may include but not be limited to keeping your assets in your former employer’s plan rolling over assets to a new employer’s plan or taking a cash distribution . Prior to a decision, be sure to understand the benefits and limitations of your available options and consider factors such as differences in investment related expenses, plan or account fees, available investment options, distribution options, legal and creditor protections, the availability of loan provisions, tax treatment, and other concerns specific to your individual circumstances.

It Will Be Easier To Calculate Your Rmd

At some point in your retirement, you will be required to take money from each retirement account that you have. These are called Required Minimum Distributions . When this starts at age 70.5, you will have multiple custodians contacting you every year to process these distributions.

If you have a lot of accounts, that means a lot of calculations need to be done. With a consolidated statement, you only need to perform one calculation.

If you fail to take out your RMDs annually, you face a 50% penalty on the amount you should have withdrawn. It becomes a lot easier to avoid those withdrawal penalties with a consolidated account.

Determine When Both Of You Will Retire

Do you know when you and your partner will retire? Remember, retirement plans like 401s and IRAs cannot be withdrawn penalty-free until you reach age 59½.

If you or your partner do plan to retire earlier than 59½, it might make sense to put some of your retirement funds into a taxable brokerage account that you can access at any time.

Also Check: How Much To Save For Retirement

What Are The Costs With An Ira Vs A New 401

When deciding whether to roll over your 401 to your new companys plan or to an IRA, you should weigh the investment costs.

A lot of people assume a 401 or other qualified plans are free for them, Hopkins says. They are not you pay the fees on the accounts. If you go with a low-cost IRA, the fees can be less than a 401 plan.

Roth Iras And Traditional Iras

The downside of cashing out assets from your retirement plan account.

There are benefits on both sides of the traditional IRA vs Roth IRA debate, but one thing is universally true: Traditional or Roth IRAs are individual retirement accountsthere can only be one owner. But while you cant have a joint IRA account, you can designate your partner as a beneficiary, so that in case anything were to happen to you, your partner would receive the funds.

Can married couples combine IRAs? No. But for couples who want to maximize the use of IRAs, each one of you can open an IRA and contribute up to $6,000 per year individually, for a combined $12,000 annually.

Some couples may not qualify for a full tax deduction for their traditional IRA, depending on their income and if they are covered by a retirement plan at work. If both are covered and file jointly, the deduction is reduced if their modified adjusted gross income is more than $109,000 the deduction phases out at a modified AGI of $129,000.

If only one is covered by a retirement plan, the deduction is reduced if their modified AGI is more than $198,000 the deduction phases out at a modified AGI of $208,000.

Recommended Reading: Can You Take Retirement Money Out

Simplify Your Retirement Planning

It’s not how many firms you have accounts with that makes your portfolio diversified, it’s the asset allocation across your accounts. Viewing your portfolio in one place makes it easier to monitor what is happening across your accounts and rebalance when necessary. Through Fidelity, you can invest in 175 Fidelity and over 10,000 non-Fidelity funds, ETFs, stocks, bonds, and more to help you build a diversified portfolio.

Managing your financial life with one provider can alleviate headaches and make it easier to have a realistic view of your cash flow, needs, and progress. Plus, having your retirement and brokerage accounts at the same firm can help you implement tax-efficient strategies.

Reason Not To Consolidate #: Backdoor Roth Ira Contributions Are More Complicated

If youre a high earner and have hit the income limitations for annual Roth IRA contributions, then the back-door Roth IRA contribution strategy may still be there for you.

However, if you roll your 401 over into an IRA, then the tax treatment of these back-door Roth IRA contributions becomes even more complicated and may make the entire process less advantageous. If you want to use this tactic every year to add funds to your Roth IRA, then consolidation may not be a good idea at this time.

That being said, the size of the 401 and the quality of its investments should be considered here. If you have a $1 million 401 with limited investment options and high fees, it may be a good idea to consider the IRA.

Also Check: Is $5 M Enough To Retire

Why You Should Consolidate Those 401s And Iras

  • Around 25 million Americans left behind money in a 401 when separating from an old job from 2004 to 2014, according to a study from the Government Accountability Office.
  • Merging multiple 401s and/or IRAs generally makes things like portfolio rebalancing and mandatory account withdrawals much simpler.
  • When leaving a job, savers are typically better off moving an old 401 account to their new workplace plan instead of an IRA, according to some financial experts.

Many Americans hold multiple retirement accounts and there are many reasons why they should consider combining those nest eggs instead of letting them gather dust.

Around 25 million Americans left behind money in a 401 account when separating from an old job, according to the Government Accountability Office, which analyzed 10 years’ worth of data from the 2004 to 2014 period. Millions left behind money in two or more accounts.

That represents about 37% of the roughly 68 million workers actively saving in a 401-type plan through their workplace, according to figures from the Labor Department.

The relatively high incidence of stranded 401 funds is understandable, given that workers over age 25 only stay at the same job for around five years, accordingto the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

More from Personal Finance:Change on tap for retirement savings, Social Security, Medicare

They can also cash out balances less than $1,000 and send a check.

Option : Rolling Over Into Your Active 401

Is it better to consolidate multiple 401ks?

Your first option with the 401 you no longer contribute to is to roll the money into your active 401 account with your current employer. This is a good option to consider if you want to have all your tax-deferred dollars in one place.


1. A single place for all tax-deferred money

2. Consolidating your investment strategy

The act of consolidation isnt just ideal for cosmetic reasons. It may make it easier to keep track of your money and manage a cohesive investment strategy. It can be challenging to manage a bunch of different retirement accounts.


1. Limited investing options

Sometimes, 401 plans have limited investing options. If you like the options that you have available, this may not be a hangup for you. By looking at the investment option information provided by your plan, you should be able to make an informed decision about how you want to direct your investment.

Before moving more money into an active 401 plan, you may want to investigate both the fees charged by the account and the investing options.

2. Additional fees

Sometimes, 401 accounts have additional fees on both the accounts and investments themselves.. Check to see if fees are assessed at a flat rate, or if they are assessed as a percentage of the amount invested. This may influence your decision to roll over other 401s into your active 401.

How to do it:

Recommended Reading: The New Rules Of Retirement Strategies For A Secure Future

Can You Combine 401 Accounts In Another 401 Plan

Whether or not you can combine 401 accounts into another 401 plan depends on the 401 plan you hope to transfer the funds into. Some plans are more flexible about transferring funds from other plans. You can check with the human resources department at your workplace for more information about what your 401 plan does and doesn’t allow.

Keep Your 401 With Your Old Employer

The biggest headache of leaving your retirement savings in your old employer’s retirement plan is trying to keep track of multiple retirement accounts. But if you are the kind of highly organized person who doesn’t mind receiving and deciphering multiple earnings summaries, consider the advantages of leaving your 401 savings right where they are.

Before you quit your current job, you need to check with your human resources department about the company’s “vesting” policy. One of the greatest perks of a 401 is that your employer matches a percentage of your contributions. But at some companies, those matching employer contributions are deleted if you leave the company before you are “fully vested” .

Vesting policies differ from company to company. Some use a gradual scale where you get to keep 25 percent of matching funds for each year with the company. Others don’t give anything if you leave before four or five years . If you are very close to being fully vested, it might be worth sticking with your current job for a few more months to save potentially thousands of dollars in free money.

Now let’s look at the advantages of consolidating your retirement accounts in a new 401 or a rollover IRA.

If you own company stock as part of your 401 plan, consider leaving it where it is, even if you move the rest of your money elsewhere. Any gains you earn on the company stock will be taxed at a lower rate if it remains in the company plan.

Read Also: When Can I Take Early Retirement

Combining 401 Accounts: How To Get Started

  • Gather your most recent 401 and IRA statements. To transfer these accounts, you need statements that are less than 90 days old.
  • Collect online rollover or transfer forms and contact information from your brokerage company or previous employer.
  • Be sure to have your 401 accounts rolled over directly to Schwab. If you don’t, you may have to pay taxes you could have avoided.

Am I Saving Enough Into My Pension

Boomers: Consolidate Retirement Accounts Now

If you want to know whether your pension pot will be enough for your retirement, there is a simple way to find out. Check out our article on how much to save into a pension or give our Pension Calculator a go to see how much retirement income you might recieve.

Here you can find out more about planning for your retirement. Did you find this article useful? Then you might also find our article on alternatives to pensions informative, too!

Also Check: Highland Springs Retirement Community Dallas

Would Compound Interest Work Better If All My Accounts Were Combined Into One

My wife and I currently have three retirement accounts from different jobs. The only one currently getting paid into is my TSP account. Would we realize better gains if we combined the other two accounts into the TSP? Say they are all earning 10% annually. From what I’ve seen on charts the compound interest curve grows exponentially. It seems like I’d have three accounts growing slower or one growing faster. Is that the case?

  • unutbuJun 18 ’18 at 20:44
  • TSP is free to use and maintain. True of your other accounts too? Does any account perform significantly better than the others? Not really “interest” at a fixed rate like savings acct, but rate of return from the various investments & index funds in the respective accounts. How do the returns stack up to each other & to your goals? Did you approach them all in the same way, or did your contributions/allocations differ? e.g. TSP “2050” fund is higher-risk than a near-term “2020” fund for someone retiring sooner. Similar allocations for all of your accounts? Maybe revisit those choices too.

No. The compounding is a multiplier, and multiplication is distributive over addition. So

1.1 * = + .

That is assuming that the accounts are large enough that no individual payment gets lost as a rounding error . So long as the accounts are at least a few hundred dollars, even if the 10% is paid daily, you shouldn’t have a problem.

Also assuming there are no fixed costs per account. Obviously those can be reduced by combining accounts.

Should You Consolidate Your Pensions

As many as 1.6 million pension pots have been lost, often because people moved house and forgot to let their pension providers know. This means £19.4 billion worth of hard-earned pension savings have been left unclaimed1.

In this article, we look at why you might consolidate your pensions and things you need to consider.

Also Check: How Much Is Social Security Taxed In Retirement

Is It Bad To Have Two Roth Iras

Having multiple Roth IRA accounts is perfectly legal, but the total amount of deposits made to both accounts must not exceed the federally set annual deposit limits.

Can I connect two Roth IRAs? Yes, each of you can create a traditional IRA and a Roth IRA and pool all of your funds into these accounts. Consolidation not only saves you money by reducing maintenance fees, but also makes it easier to track your investments.

Is Roth Conversion Going Away

What Is The Best Way To Consolidate Multiple 401k Plans?

From 2022, the bill proposes to end the Roth conversions of the so-called non-deductible backdoor and mega backdoor. Regardless of your income level, you can no longer convert 401 or traditional IRA contributions to a Roth IRA.

Are Roth conversions allowed in 2021?

Roth IRA Conversion Limits The government will only allow you to deposit $ 6,000 or $ 7,000 directly into a Roth IRA in 2021 and 2022 if you are 50 years of age or older, but there is no limit to how much you can convert your Roth money into deferred tax savings. IRA in one year.

Are Roth conversions still allowed?

Even if your income exceeds the Roth IRA deposit limit, you can still make a Roth conversion, sometimes called a backdoor Roth IRA. You owe a payment on the convertible money, but you can withdraw from the Roth IRA tax-free in the future.

You May Like: Retirement Home St Augustine Fl

The Drawbacks Of Too Many Retirement Accounts

Hopefully it’s now clear that having one retirement account can be too restrictive, but having too many retirement accounts can make managing your savings much more challenging.

The obvious issue is that it becomes difficult to know what you have when your money is spread across a half dozen or more retirement accounts. When setting up a new one, you might forget what you have invested in some of your other accounts. This could lead to you exposing yourself to too much risk in a certain area.

Some people even forget about some of their retirement savings altogether when they have too many retirement accounts. This happens sometimes if people leave their old 401 where it is when they quit their job instead of rolling it over into their new 401 or an IRA. If this happens enough times, it can become difficult to keep track of where all your savings are, especially if your 401 plan administrator changes after you’ve left the company.

Leaving a bunch of 401s with all your old employers can also cost you a lot more than necessary. If these 401s have high fees, you can save by rolling them over into an IRA rather than leaving the money where it is.

What Online Brokers Have Custodial Accounts

  • Best of all: Charles Schwab. Register now.
  • Best College Savings: TD Ameritrade.
  • Best for Custodian Accounts: Ally Bank.
  • The best investment for teaching children: stocks.
  • Best for Mutual Funds: Vanguard.
  • Best Robo Advisor: FutureAdvisor.
  • The most well-established web broker: E * TRADE.

Can I set up a Robinhood account for my child?

Robinhood does not allow anyone under the age of 18 to invest. Investing as a minor requires the opening of so-called depository accounts. Until now, holding investment services have been expensive. Loved allows you to invest for everyone under the age of 18, free of charge.

Can you open a custodial account online?

You can open a maintenance account for your child both a regular brokerage account and a Roth IRA in about 15 minutes most brokers complete the entire process online. To speed things up, make sure you have the information you need.

You May Like: John Hancock Retirement Phone Number

A Solution For Every Saver

We’re on a mission to help everyone enjoy a happy retirement, by creating a pension that’s fit for the 21st century.

Our website and mobile app gives you tools to help manage your pension, whether you’re combining pensions for the first time through our pension consolidation service, getting your pension contributions back on track or you’re ready to start making pension withdrawals. Everything is designed to give you pension peace of mind.

Combining my 5 old workplace pensions was easy. I now feel secure about the future.


It Takes A Little Work But It Could Make Your Life A Lot Easier In The Long Run


Chances are, you’ll probably hold quite a few jobs in your lifetime, and you may also accumulate several retirement accounts along the way. You’re free to leave that money where it is when you head for greener pastures, but you can also consolidate your retirement accounts by rolling over old 401s into your new 401 or into an IRA. Here are a few reasons consolidating your retirement accounts might be the better approach.

Don’t Miss: State Of Connecticut Retirement Division

Share post:


More like this