New York State Teachers Retirement System


New York State Teachers 403 Tda Rollovers

Report: 2,900 public retirees in NY with $100,000 pensions

Rolling over a 403 allows eligible employees to defer income taxes on retirement savings into future years. If youre about to retire, you have an important decision to make about your plan. Rolling over your 403 balance to an IRA may give you more control of your hard earned assets and more flexibility to manage your retirement nest egg.

Frequently a 403 is rolled into a Traditional IRA using a trustee-to-trustee transfer, meaning that a direct rollover from a 403 to an IRA is made tax-free with no tax liability. It is generally to your advantage to choose a direct rollover because your 403 plan administrator will not withhold taxes if you choose this option.

A 403 rollover into an IRA can offer advantages:

If you are considering a rollover, it is important to note that:

Are you a New York State Teacher considering a 403 rollover? Call now at 631.393.2888 to schedule a complimentary consultation to discuss whether rolling over your 403 makes sense for you and your loved ones financial future.

Rollovers are not suitable for everyone. Please consider all options prior to making a decision.

Neither United Planners nor its representatives provide tax or legal advice.

Earnings Limit Suspended Through July 29 2022 For Other Public Employers

Since the start of the COVID-19 emergency, governors have issued executive orders temporarily suspending the retiree earnings limit. Under the executive orders, post-retirement earnings with a public employer will not count toward a retirees annual earnings limit during the following time periods:

If the order is extended beyond July 29, 2022 we will update this blog post. For general information about post-retirement employment, please read What If I Work After Retirement.

New York State Teachers Returns 35% In Fiscal 2020

New York State Teachers’ Retirement System, Albany, returned a net 3.5% on its investments for the fiscal year ended June 30, according to an annual report posted recently on the system’s website.

The 3.5% return was down from the net 7.1% in the previous fiscal year and was the lowest since the system’s 2.3% net return in fiscal year 2016.

The system’s assumed annualized rate of return is 7.1%.

The pension system’s assets as of June 30 totaled $120.48 billion, down slightly from the $122.48 billion for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2019.

“Despite continued economic uncertainty, NYSTRS remains exceptionally well-funded,” David P. Keefe, president of the system’s board of trustees, said in a message accompanying the annual report. “As of our last actuarial valuation, NYSTRS was 101.2% funded based on a market value of assets and 99.6% funded based on an actuarial value of assets.”

The annualized net return was 6.5% for three years and 6.8% for five years, both as of June 30. Also as of that date, the annualized net return was 9.6% for 10 years and 8.6% for 30 years, according to the annual report.

Read Also: Best Small Towns In North Carolina To Retire

How Do Teacher Pensions Work In New York

Teachers in New York are members of the Teachers Retirement System, which was created in 1921. However, New York City instructors are a part of a separate system that is exclusively for city educators.

The fundamental structure of New York States teacher-defined benefit pension is comparable to that of other states. A teachers contributions and those established on their place by the state or school district do not influence the pensions value at retirement, as they do with other pensions.

Although those investments are invested in private equity and hedge funds, a teachers pension wealth isnt obtained from the returns on those investments. Alternatively, it is determined by a formula based on experience and final salary.

In most states, including New York, there are different benefits for teachers depending on when they were hired. Teachers who were hired in April 2012 or later belonged to Tier 6.

Here Are Details About School Pensions In New York


The number of participants and average annual amount of those in the education pension system were relatively flat last year compared to 2018. Each has grown about 5% since 2015.

What has grown more, though, is the number of people earning a pension of $100,000 or more as a surge in older teachers and administrators retire, fueling a teaching shortage in some parts of New York.

The number of active educators in the system fell from 285,774 in 2010 to 263,517 last year, a drop of nearly 8%. But the number of retirees jumped from 141,716 in 2010 to 169,203 in 2019, a 19% increase, the retirement system’s annual report showed.

More:Educator salaries in New York: See how much they were paid last school year

The number of high pension earners was up 6% since last year and 36% since 2015.

The highest pension recipient continues to be James Feltman, the former superintendent in Commack on Long Island. He gets an annual pension of $327,000 a year.

The New York State United Teachers union has long maintained that the pensions are the result of the experience and education of its workers.

The retirement system said 53% of its pensioners worked 30 years or more to earn it, and about 30% get $30,000 or less per year.

New Yorks educators are dedicated to ensuring that our children receive a high-quality public education,” NYSUT spokesman Matt Hamilton said.

More:New York state budget 2020: 9 proposals that could impact your wallet

You May Like: Top 10 Retirement Communities In The United States

Nys Teachers Retirement Systemsalaries

Highest salary at Nys Teachers Retirement System in year 2018 was $276,444.Number of employees at Nys Teachers Retirement System in year 2018was 396. Average annual salarywas $74,404 and median salarywas $64,810. Nys Teachers Retirement System average salaryis 59 percent higher than USA average and mediansalary is 49percent higher than USA median.

GovSalaries is not affiliated with any government entity. We cannot makeanyguarantee that information on this website 100% accurate or complete. GovSalaries is not aconsumerreporting agency as defined by the Fair Credit Reporting Act, 15 USC § 1681 et seq, . We strictlyprohibit the use of this website or the information it contains to make any determinations concerningemployment, consumer credit, insurance, tenant screening, or any other purpose that would require FCRAcompliance.

Who Is Entitled To A Teacher Pension In New York

Like other states, teachers need to work for many years before they can get a pension. Under Tier 6, New York urges a 10-year vesting period. While teachers qualify for a pension after ten years of service, the pension may not be worth all that much and cant begin to collect it until they hit the states retirement age.

Teachers in Texas can retire with benefits at a certain age and years of experience. Teachers in Tier 6 may retire with a lower payout at the age of 55 if they have at least ten years of service, but they must wait until they are 63 to receive complete payments.

You May Like: Madrona Hills Retirement Salem Oregon

How Much Does New Yorks Teacher Pension Plan Cost

The employers and teachers must contribute to the plan throughout its duration. The state legislature determines the contribution rates, which can change from year to year.

Teachers in Level 6 may make a variable contribution based on their compensation.

In 2019, employers contributed 10.62% of a teachers pay to the pension system. While all of a teachers contributions are spent on benefits, a portion of the employers payments goes toward paying off the pension plans debts. The amount will change from year to year.

Finally, in New York, as in most states, teacher pensions are not portable. This implies that if an NYSTRS teacher quits working, they will forfeit their benefits and be unable to take them with them if they pursue another profession.

As a result, if someone leaves teaching or goes across state lines, they may obtain two pensions, but the sum of those two is more likely to be less than if they had stayed in one System throughout their careers.

In other words, the lack of portability will hinder any educators long-term retirement savings if she or he leaves teaching entirely or works in another state.

Long-serving teachers receive the greatest benefits from New Yorks teacher retirement system, while all others are left with inadequate benefits. As a result, current and new teachers should carefully consider their career plans in relation to this state pension plan.

What State Has The Best Teacher Retirement Plan

Erie County tops list of highest paid teachers in Upstate New York

The state that has the best teacher retirement plan is South Dakota. This state is the one that comes most close to earning 100% of possible points by earning 88.4% of all possible points. Other states that also ranked high include Tennessee and Washington . The worst scores were earned by Kentucky , New Jersey , and Illinois .

Also Check: How Do I Apply For Early Retirement

Tier 3 And Tier 4 Members:

  • If you left public employment with less than five years of credited service, you may choose to terminate your membership and withdraw your accumulated contributions plus interest. If you do not terminate your membership, once seven years have elapsed since your last public employment, your membership will terminate automatically as required by Retirement Law. You can receive a refund of your contributions by filing a Withdrawal Application . Note that interest on your contributions ceases after seven years of inactivity.
  • If you leave public employment with at least five, but less than ten, years of credited service, you may choose to:
  • Terminate your membership and withdraw your accumulated contributions plus interest or
  • Leave your contributions in your account and qualify for a retirement benefit when you are age 55.
  • To help you decide which would be more beneficial, you can use Retirement Online to compare the amount of your withdrawal payment to your continuing pension benefit. and go to the My Account Summary section of your Account Homepage. Click Withdraw My Membership to see your withdrawal payment information. Click Estimate my Pension Benefit to create an estimate. You can also go to the Estimate Your Pension page and use our Quick Calculator.
  • If you have ten or more years of credited service, you cannot withdraw from the New York State and Local Retirement System.
  • Data Notes: Nys Teachers Retirement System

    The New York State Teachers Retirement System data, as provided by the New York State Teachers Retirement System , includes names, maximum allowable benefit rates, retirement dates and last known employers when available for every individual who collected benefits.

    NYSTRS Pension data reflects information that is current as of December 31 for the years 2008 through 2017.

    Other LINKS

    The Empire Center is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit think tank located in Albany, New York. Our mission is to make New York a better place to live and work by promoting public policy reforms grounded in free-market principles, personal responsibility, and the ideals of effective and accountable government.


    Use this site to share, analyze and compare data from governmental entities throughout New York. The information on this website comes from official government sources, but the Empire Center cannot guarantee data accuracy or completeness.

    You May Like: How Much Retirement Should I Have At 30

    Ers Tier 6 Benefits A Closer Look

    Financial advisers say you will need to replace between 70 and 80 percent of your salary to maintain your lifestyle after retirement. Your NYSLRS pension could go a long way in helping you reach that goal, especially when combined with your Social Security benefit and your own retirement savings. Heres a look at how Employees Retirement System members in Tier 6 , can reach that goal. Members who joined NYSLRS since April 1, 2012 are in Tier 6.

    Keep Up With Today’s Most Important News

    New York State Teachers Retirement System  Quantum Engineering

    Stay up on the very latest with Evening Update.

    The New York State Teachers Retirement System, NYSTERS, which represents public-school teachers outside of NYC, passed a resolution on March 4 to divest of Russian-related assets worth $125 million. It did not give the current market value.

    Theyre just trapped, John Murphy, former executive director of NYCERS, said of the pension systems.There is a risk that they will lose all their money on these companies.

    Even if the pension systems could divest, They couldnt sell at any reasonable price. Theres no market for the securities because of global outrage over the war, said Edward Siedle, a former Securities and Exchange Commission lawyer and investigator.

    The city and states $519 million is just 0.1 percent of the total $263.2 billion the city pension systems manage as of March.

    The state employee pension systems $110.8 million in Russian stocks, as estimated March 1, comes to .03 of its $279.7 billion in assets. And the state teachers pension system had Russian stocks worth $125 million on March 4 or .08 percent of its $152.4 billion in assets.

    But the publicly traded Russian investments are likely just the tip of the iceberg, Siedle said.

    City and state pension systems, in hopes of making a profit, enter secretive contracts with private equity, hedge funds and real-estate investment firms that do not disclose where they sink hundreds of millions of dollars.

    Sberbank/ Herman Gref /$133.3M

    Also Check: New York Life Retirement Plan

    New York State Teachers Retirement System

    Us Announces $820m In Ukraine Aid Including Missile Systems

    New York employees and taxpayers are unwittingly financing Russian companies and the oligarch pals of Vladimir Putin with at least $519 million invested in assets now frozen by the war-mongering dictator, The Post has learned.

    City and state pension systems have pledged to sell off the holdings in protest of Russias assault on Ukraine, but Moscow has prohibited foreign investors from dumping the stocks.

    Putin is a thug and hes holding our money hostage, said Gregory Floyd, a Teamsters union leader and trustee of the New York City Employee Retirement System, NYCERS.

    New York Citys five pension systems covering teachers, cops, firefighters and other city employees have invested a total $284.5 million in 33 publicly traded Russian stocks, according to records released to The Post by city Comptroller Brad Landers office.

    On Feb. 25, the market value of the Russian assets was $185.9 million, nearly $100 million less than the purchase price, the latest available records show.

    Landers office says it cant put a finger on what the Russian stocks are worth today.

    The market remains closed to all non-Russian investors, spokeswoman Shaquana Chaneyfield said. Strong sanctions are in place that prohibit us from transacting any Russian securities. Given that context and constantly shifting rules in the Russian market, an accurate assessment of their current value is not available at this time.

    NYC pension systems invested $6.4 million in Gazprom.

    You May Like: How To Choose Retirement Funds

    Thoughts On Update Regarding Retiree Earnings Limit During Covid

  • Cheryl Pushlar
  • At this time, we are not aware of any plan by the Governor to extend the waiver of the retiree earnings limit beyond June 29, 2022. If there are future developments concerning the earnings limit, we will update this blog post.

  • My employer, from whom I retired 06/2016 and with whom I work part time, is a 4201 school. We serve students who are Deaf, blind and/or physically challenged. We are not charter, district or BOCES programs we are state supported & privately run. How does the education salary extension affect me? Is the extension of the salary cap through June 2023 applicable to me?

  • May 19, 2022 at 3:35 pm

    I can make as much as I want up until June 2023 is that correct? The $35,000 limit does not start back again until June 2023 correct? So I just cant make more than $35,000 starting from June 2023 till the end of 2023 right?

  • May 20, 2022 at 12:57 pm

    Under current legislation, if you work for a school district or BOCES, pay earned through June 30, 2023 will not count toward your post-retirement earnings limit.

    For account-specific information about how this may apply in your situation, please email our customer service representatives using our secure email form. Filling out the secure form allows them to safely contact you about your personal account information.

  • According to CSA the income limitis waived through June 2023,

  • Seth Gilbertson
  • Other Retirement Plans For Teachers

    Nearly 5,000 New York State retirees receiving $100K or more in pensions

    Aside from the benefits provided by the New York State Teachers Retirement System, individual employers may offer additional retirement plans, such as 403 plan and 457 deferred compensation plans, that offer greater flexibility than NYSTRS pensions.

    A 403 is a tax-advantaged retirement plan offered only by public schools and certain 501 tax-exempt organizations. A 403 plan functions similar to a 401 plan, as it allows employees to defer their some of their salary into individual accounts, sheltering it from income tax until distribution. For 2020, the annual elective deferral limit is $19,500, though employees age 50 or older may contribute an additional $6,500 for a total of $26,000. The total contribution limit for both employee and employer contributions rests at $57,000, or $63,500 if age 50 or older. Though somewhat less common, some teachers may hold 457 plans.

    These alternative retirement accounts are eligible to be rolled over into other qualified retirement plans, such as traditional or Roth IRAs. Especially following a separation of service, you may want to consider a rollover!

    Don’t Miss: Vanguard Target Retirement 2030 Review

    Other Details About New York’s Teacher Pension System

    Of the active members in the system, 45% had 10 years or less of service, the data showed, and about 35% were 39 years of age or younger.

    So they have 16 years or more before they will be eligible to collect a pension.

    Pension costs have long been a concern for local districts, and in 2011, New York created a new pension tier that limits the benefits of new workers.

    As a result, 26% of public educators are in the Tier 6 system, which requires higher contributions from employees than some of the other tiers.

    For the upcoming school year, districts will need to spend between 9.25% and 10.25% of their payroll to cover pension costs, which could be as much as a 16% increase over what they are currently spending, the retirement system announced in November.

    The higher pension costs come as districts will ask voters in May to approve their school budgets for the fiscal year that starts July 1.

    Districts are also dealing with a lower property-tax cap than in recent years. The limit on the growth in school taxes is 1.81%, Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli announced earlier this month.

    The system said it distributed more than $7 billion in benefits last year, and 80% went to New York residents.

    Share post:


    More like this

    Retirement Income Calculator With Inflation

    Making Your...

    How Much Do I Need In 401k To Retire

    What Is...

    What To Do With Tsp After Retirement

    Tsp Installment...

    Good Places To Retire In Virginia

    Virginia Is...